Comedians get and give advice all the time. It is constantly a learning process, and not one person knows everything about comedy. How you take advice and/or criticism is important if you want to grow.
Advice can come in many forms, but no matter how you get it make sure you understand the source. I am not saying that only famous people can give advice because a lot of the time it was just blind luck that got them famous! You have to weight what advice from a certain sources means to you. I am nowhere near famous, and I have dispensed advice on this blog for three years now. You reading this are the only ones that will know if what I say applies to you and your career. If you are headlining clubs every weekend you have no business here. I will add hardly anything to your overall understanding of the comedy industry. If you’re an open mic comedian, that is trying to move up the ladder, then maybe you can get something from all of these scribbles. There is also nothing saying you can’t take bits and pieces of advice and make it something that can help you grow. If someone tells you, “You need to get on stage more and face the crowd.”, but the persona you are building on stage is one that is stand offish to the audience, then maybe just take “You need to get on stage more.” and leave the rest to the winds.
Criticism is hard for any entertainer. Who wants to know that you are not making 100% of people laugh? I have been doing this for twelve years, and I still get down whenever I hear someone tell me that. I will tell you the same thing I told you in the paragraph above: understand the source! Criticism coming from a drunk person may not be the same as it is coming from your buddy. Is this person just trying to hurt your feelings? That is something else to take into account. I am not saying that anyone that has a criticism about you is a hater, but listen to the criticism. Is it constructive? Does it give you a starting point in which you can improve, or is it just tearing you down just for the sake of it? Constructive criticism is almost always trying to negate negativity by instilling a positive aspect. Here is an example: Someone comes to you after a performance, and says, “I think you should shed some details in your stories. The end is funny, but it takes to long to get there.” They are telling you that the stories you are telling on stage are too long, but they are giving you a way to change it. If they approached you and just said, “Your stories suck.” you just have the negative and no way of changing anything for the better. You also have to understand that there is no way 100% of people are going to find what you do funny. You are not looking for 100% anyway. You are looking for enough people that will fill up a room. I am not saying don’t try to make the person that doesn’t like you laugh, but don’t kill yourself trying to do it.
It is important to note that not all advice and not all criticism is good. I once had someone after a show tell me, “What you need to do is get on Comedy Central!” That is advice, but I can not do anything with that! I had someone just a couple of hours ago say they have never liked my material (the inspiration for this post), until recently. That’s all they said. That is criticism, but since they gave me nothing else to go off of, there is nothing I can do to see if it is something I can fix. There is nothing wrong with going head first with our vision of what you want to do on stage. The thing is, we are trying to entertain others, and if we are not trying to do the best we can to do that, then we are just amusing our need to be the center of attention when we are on stage.